Island Fertility, Stony Brook Community Medical, PC
4.3117 verified reviews

Island Fertility, Stony Brook Community Medical, PC

500 Commack Rd, Suite 202, Commack, NY 11725 Fertility & IVF center

Highlights

Anesthesia included

No surprise anesthesia fees bundled into eligible treatment pricing.

1 year storage included

One year of storage is included where listed by the clinic.

Insurance

Fertility assessments and treatments may be covered depending on your plan.

High volume in egg freezing

Clinic reports strong experience for this treatment category.

About Island Fertility, Stony Brook Community Medical, PC

Island Fertility, Stony Brook Community Medical, PC provides fertility care and treatment information for patients comparing clinics in Commack, NY.

Treatments offered

IVF

In vitro fertilization with clinic-reported pricing where available.

IUI

Intrauterine insemination options for eligible patients.

Egg & embryo freezing

Fertility preservation support and storage details.

Genetic testing

Embryo testing information where offered by the clinic.

Donor egg & sperm

Third-party reproduction coordination where available.

LGBTQ+ family building

Inclusive fertility pathways for families.

Success rates

Verified clinical data — percentage of live births from intended IVF cycles versus the national average, broken down by patient age.

Overall: Below average

CDC IVF success rates — Island Fertility, Stony Brook Community Medical, PC
National averageThis clinic — better than averageThis clinic — below average
51%40%
37%26%
24%19%
8%5%
<35 yo35-37 yo38-40 yo40+ yo
<35 yoBelow average
35-37 yoBelow average
38-40 yoBelow average
40+ yoBelow average

Doctors

Lead fertility specialist Lead physician

Reproductive Endocrinology (REI)

Ask clinic

Reproductive surgery specialist

Reproductive Surgery

Ask clinic

Clinical care team

Fertility care coordination

Ask clinic

Cost of treatment

Clinic-reported pricing and affordability details where available.

Fertility consultation
Freeor covered by most insurance plans
Egg freezing$9,000per cycle, when listed
IVF cycle$18,000-30,000per cycle, when listed
Financing
$
Ask clinicAffordability options

Reviews

4.3
Based on 117 verified reviews
Jennifer Durkovic
5.0· a month ago
Verified

I am incredibly grateful for the exceptional care I received at Island Fertility. From my first visit, the staff made me feel welcomed and supported during a deeply personal and emotional journey. During that initial visit, I had a memorable moment in the waiting room when a lady came in with a gorgeous baby and asked for Dr. Lauren Safier (Ivy League, MD, graduated from Cornell). She wanted to show Dr. Safier the beautiful baby that she helped to bring into the world. It was a heartwarming sight that instantly inspired hope in me and reminded me of the incredible impact Island Fertility has on so many families. Dr. Safier and the entire team at Island Fertility took the time to listen to my concerns and answered all my questions with patience and compassion. Their expertise and dedication were evident every step of the way. I appreciated the personalized treatment plan tailored to my specific needs, which made me feel valued as a patient. The warm and caring environment at Island Fertility helped ease my anxiety, and I always felt like I was in good hands. The communication throughout the process was outstanding, and I always knew what to expect. Thanks to the incredible support from everyone at Island Fertility, I am now feeling hopeful about my journey. I cannot recommend Island Fertility enough to anyone seeking fertility treatment. Thank you for everything 💕🐣💕 Love, Jennie💕

Eric T
1.0· 2 months ago
Verified

Posting for my wife bc she’s just besides herself. We came to this office looking for help to conceive. They told us insurance would cover everything we spoke about. A month later we received 2 bills. One from the office for $800 and one from the lab for $3000!!!! Going thru what we had to go thru and then ending up with a bill like that is crazy. To top it off, we have been trying to speak with sometime regarding the bills but no one will call us back. We’ve left voicemails and emails numerous times! We’ve received a response once stating they will look into it. 8 months later and still no answers to emails or calls back. I will never step foot in this place again. Very unprofessional and not helpful at all!! Today I wrote my last email to them, stating my feelings on the subject and guess what someone called me back. I’m at work so I missed the call and I called back and what do you know, answering machine again. That was my last straw so here I am telling you about my experience. If you go here, good luck!

Denise Castilletti
5.0· 3 months ago
Verified

I had an amazing experience at Island Fertility, I highly recommend this office for any fertility concerns. The entire staff is compassionate, knowledgeable, and incredibly supportive throughout the entire process. They truly go above and beyond to ensure you feel cared for every step of the way.

Emily Okun
5.0· 5 months ago
Verified

I have been working with Dr. Hershlag since May and he has been beyond patient with me. We tried multiple rounds of clomid and letrozole, but unfortunately it did not work. Soon will he starting IVF and I could not be more excited and positive that it will work. Dr. hershlag makes my husband and I feel calm and excited about the future of our children! Highly recommend this practice & Dr. Hershlag!!

Katie Tardif
5.0· 5 months ago
Verified

I cannot say enough good things about the staff here and my overall experience—Dr. Trivax is by far the best doctor I've ever had. He's approachable, compassionate, and makes you feel totally normal, calm and supported during these sensitive experiences. The entire team is highly communicative, always transparent and prompt with updates and scheduling. The only issue I encountered was with billing—we received unexpected large bills despite multiple discussions about fees, as we were paying out of pocket. Somehow, they still failed to provide all the necessary information. If you're looking for a responsive, transparent, caring team, I highly recommend Island Fertility, but be sure to ask finance as many detailed questions as possible, as they won’t always volunteer all the information upfront.

See all reviews

Location

500 Commack Rd, Suite 202, Commack, NY 11725

Get directions